SEOClerks

Is Google's algorithm so complex not even its engineers fully understand it?



Enter a reason for deleting this comment

Is Google's algorithm so complex not even its engineers fully understand it?

Google's search and ranking algorithm have become so gigantic and complex that apparently, not even the engineers working at Google fully understand it. 

Google's search algorithm has always been complex and people always tried to crack the code behind it to make their website rank higher in the search results. This isn't a mystery really, this is how search engine optimization as born! 

Danny Sullivan from Search Engine Land said the following:

Google’s own engineers tell me and others they don’t even really understand how it works. Ultimately, the best way to “rank” for RankBrain remains that same boring thing no one wants to hear despite it being true. Have really good, descriptive content.
But a recent statement made by John Mueller (a trends analysis and webmaster at Google) tries to dismiss all of this:
Is Google

Source

Of course, Google is trying to dismiss all of this! I personally talked with a couple Google employees at various events and I even participated in an interview with Google. Like any other tech company out there that has certain people that have very specific roles inside the company. Depending on your department you are on a need to know basis and won't get too technical involved with other departments. So I'm pretty sure the most search engineers at Google don't fully understand or know the whole algorithm.

As far as lead engineers go, maybe but I have my doubts about understanding the whole picture on a detailed level. 
Sure, maybe they get the big picture, but what scares me is that the algorithm as grown so complex, that no employee understands it at its full form, this together with the new Rank Brian update which is essentially is artificial intelligence makes me believe that Google's algorithm is unique in the tech industry and some day may take over the world. 

Joke aside this clearly shows SEO experts are limited in their powers. Sure, some SEOs are very successful in ranking websites and do SEO better than the majority but that doesn't mean by any means, they cracked Google's ranking algorithm. If most Google's engineers don't know the big picture, don't expect an SEO to implement miracles. This was for all the SEOs out there to claim they can get anyone on 1st position on any keyword as well as the clients that believe such SEOs exist! 

So, what do you think? Is Google in full control over its search and ranking algorithm, does any Google employee fully understand the code behind all of this or did they lost that ability a long time ago?
Let discuss this in the comments below! 

Comments

Please login or sign up to leave a comment

Join
centurion

Hello
Have a wondeeful day.

Google search and result follow an algorithm which are very very easy for any engineer. Google search engine algorithm is in case of search that when google show the search engine result than the results come by a format. Like a title within 50 words, a description within 150 words, some pure images of the website and some keywords with the search results. So when we make social media bookmark or backlink- than we will follow this rules. Title-50 words, description-150 words, some keywords, some images and website url. This is the search criteria or search algorithm of google search engine. If any one search by a keyword than google search engine will show the results on this format.

This is called google search algorithm.

This is easy to understand for any one.


Thanks
Centurion



Enter a reason for deleting this comment

overcast

I think the issue is with the modules broken down. They have different departments for each algorithm part. For example search query for business goes local. SEO results for generic queries are handled by SEO Teams. And spam team handles different department. So the engineers working on each module must be different. So that's why not all engineers known all the algorithm.



Enter a reason for deleting this comment

Corzhens

Maybe it can be true that there is no single person who knows the algorithm that is being used by Google. It is a top secret, isn’t it? It may be similar to the world’s most guarded secret which is the formula for Coke. That soda drink which is always number 1 in sales anywhere in the world, its formula is kept in a vault and no one person knows the entire formula. Don’t ask me how they do it but I guess that same scheme is being used by Google in their algorithm.



Enter a reason for deleting this comment

jaymish2

I don't think they do. Google is a huge corporation. One of the most important corporations we have had in history. Imagine if the whole search engine were to go down. I think for security sake the algorithm is created by many people at Google and combined to come up with one large algorithm that's so that one person does not have the key to the whole algorithm. Its like algorithm has its own personality. I think as a world we are creating something that could be really dangerous.



Enter a reason for deleting this comment